Data integration approaches compared
Traditional approach
Data is transformed in a separate processing layer before loading into the target system. Clean, structured data arrives ready for analysis.
Modern cloud approach
Raw data loaded directly into the target system, then transformed using the data warehouse's processing power. Leverages modern cloud scalability.
| Aspect | ETL | ELT |
|---|---|---|
| Transformation Location | Separate ETL server/tool | Within data warehouse |
| Processing Speed | Limited by ETL server capacity | Leverages warehouse scalability |
| Data Availability | After transformation completes | Immediately after load |
| Raw Data Access | Not retained in warehouse | Full raw data available |
| Flexibility | Re-transform requires re-extract | Re-transform from loaded data |
| Infrastructure | Dedicated ETL servers needed | Uses warehouse compute |
| Data Governance | Controlled before loading | Applied after loading |
| Best For | On-premise, strict governance | Cloud, big data, agile analytics |
Extract and load raw data from sources
Store and process data at scale
Transform data within warehouse
Modern ELT Pattern: Use tools like Fivetran for data ingestion, Snowflake/BigQuery for storage and compute, and dbt for SQL-based transformations. This stack enables version-controlled, testable, and documented data transformations.